Gavin Smith (film studio executive)
Picture distributed by LA County Sheriff's Department to help find Smith
December 10, 1954|
San Fernando Valley, California
May 1, 2012 (aged 57)|
Oak Park, California
|Status||May 1, 2014Declared dead in absentia)(aged 59) (|
October 26, 2014
|Alma mater||UCLA, Hawaii|
|Occupation||Executive at 20th Century Fox|
|Known for||Member of 1975 NCAA champion men's basketball team; single-season scoring record at Hawaii|
Gavin Smith (December 10, 1954 – disappeared May 1, 2012) was an American college basketball star, actor, stuntman, and film studio executive, formerly a regional manager of distribution for 20th Century Fox. Prior to his eighteen years in that position he played basketball at UCLA, where he was part of the 1975 team that won that year's NCAA championship, the last for legendary coach John Wooden. He later played at Hawaii, where he set the school's still-standing single-season scoring record of 23.4 points per game. He had a small role as a bartender in Cobb, the 1994 biopic of baseball legend Ty Cobb.
On the night of May 1, 2012, Smith left a friend's house in Oak Park, California, where he had been staying due to reported marital difficulties. It does not appear he planned to be away long. When he failed to pick up one of his sons for school the next morning, his family reported him missing. Two years later, with Smith still missing and no evidence of his presence anywhere past the night of his disappearance, he was retroactively declared legally dead. Several months later, on October 26, 2014, hikers chanced upon Smith's remains near Palmdale in the Antelope Valley.
In January 2015, John Lenzie Creech, a convicted drug dealer who had begun an eight-year prison sentence on that charge shortly after Smith disappeared, was arrested again and charged with the murder. His wife, Chandrika Cade-Creech, had reportedly been romantically involved with Smith. Creech's attorney said the death was a "tragic accident." According to testimony before the grand jury that indicted Creech on the murder charge, he allegedly beat Smith to death after catching him and his wife together. Creech was convicted of voluntary manslaughter on July 3, 2017.
Early life and education
A native of the San Fernando Valley, the 6-foot-6-inch (198 cm) Gavin Smith was a star player on the Van Nuys High School boys' basketball team in the early 1970s. He was named a second-team All-American by Parade magazine as a senior in 1973. Smith went on to attend the University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA) and play there for coach John Wooden. In his sophomore year he was a forward on the 1975 team which won that year's NCAA championship, Wooden's tenth and last.
Smith did not play in UCLA's 92–85 title-game defeat of Kentucky. The next season was his best at UCLA, as he appeared in all but two games, averaging 5.9 points per game (ppg). In the 1976 Final Four, he appeared twice. Against Indiana, the eventual champs, he scored six points, adding eight points and four rebounds in the third-place game victory over Rutgers. After the season, he transferred to Hawaii for a season and finished his playing career there, setting the school's single-season scoring record of 23.4 ppg, a mark that still stands despite the subsequent introduction of the three-point field goal.
While at Hawaii, Smith became recognizable for complementing his then long hair with a bandana, and bringing his dog to practice. Former Rainbow Warriors coach Riley Wallace, who coached against Smith at the time, remembered him as a formidable opponent. "He frustrated me as a coach," Wallace recalls. "He could score from anywhere on the floor ... [he was] probably one of the best shooters in the history of Hawaii."
Smith eventually began a career in the film industry, at first in front of the camera. He made his acting debut playing a bodyguard in a televised adaptation of Elmore Leonard's Glitz. The following year, he had a small role in Greg Mottola's debut short, "Swingin' in the Painter's Room."
After playing a bartender in the 1994 film Cobb, a biopic of baseball player Ty Cobb, Smith went into the business side of the industry as an executive. He took a job in 20th Century Fox's distribution department, making sure that films got to the theaters they were scheduled to appear in. While he was not involved with the creative aspect of the business, he has been credited with helping films such as Titanic, Avatar and the rereleases of the original Star Wars trilogy succeed.
By 2012 he was Fox's regional branch manager for theaters in the Dallas and Oklahoma City areas, working out of the company's Calabasas offices. He had settled in the West Hills area of the Valley with his wife, Lisa, and three sons. One, Evan, had followed in his father's athletic footsteps, playing basketball for UCLA's crosstown rival, the University of Southern California. According to friends, he had talked about returning to acting when he retired from Fox, as he expected to do in a few years.
Regarding the Smiths' financial problems, they had bought their house when the market was booming and prices were high. "Upside-down" as a result of the Panic of 2008, the market value of his home plunged to less than the balance owed on the mortgage, leaving him under significant pressure, steeped in a negative equity position. They were trying to sell the house.
Smith attended CinemaCon, the annual convention of the National Association of Theatre Owners in Las Vegas. Upon his return to the Los Angeles area, he went not to his West Hills home but, due to recent problems in his marriage, that of a female colleague and family friend who lived on Kellwood Court in nearby Oak Park. The Smith family says the overnight stay at Gavin's friend's home was planned. Recent marital difficulties had led Evan Smith to criticize his father for "leaving the family" in a tweet (since deleted) two weeks earlier. He reportedly stopped speaking to Gavin as well. Evan later denied his parents were separating, saying "they were just going through normal stuff couples go through."
According to the friend Smith was staying with, the two were up watching television until sometime after 9 p.m. When the friend went to bed, Smith told her he would be following shortly. Instead, around 10 p.m., he apparently got into his black 2000 Mercedes-Benz E420 with California license plate 6EKT044, and left. One report claims someone on the street actually saw the car as it departed. Lisa Smith, who had been busy attending to her ill mother, says she spoke with him during the day to arrange for him to pick up one of their other sons from school the morning of May 2.
His family agreed it was unlike Smith to leave the house in the late evening without plans to do so, or at least giving notice that the trip was unplanned. Their family friend reported that when she last saw Smith he was wearing the purple workout pants he'd borrowed from Evan, with the intent of wearing them off to bed. This choice of clothing, they believe, makes it unlikely Smith's sudden departure was expected, or that he was going somewhere he anticipated being seen. Furthermore, that he'd left his cellphone charger, a shaving kit, and other personal belongings at the Oak Park residence, likelihood loomed large Smith did not expect anything beyond an immediate return.
In May 2014, two years after Smith was last seen, law enforcement officials declared Gavin Smith dead and a judge issued a death certificate. His date of death was declared to have been the night he disappeared. "I think the idea of a person that goes missing out of nowhere is intriguing and tragic," said a spokesman for the LACSD.
When Smith did not show up the next morning, at work nor to pick up his son, his family and coworkers reported him missing. Among the personal belongings that he did take with him when he left the Oak Park house were his cell phone and credit cards. Neither had been used since his disappearance. They could not identify anyone who might have had a reason to harm him, but believed that his fate or whereabouts were known. "We know someone knows something. There's no doubt that someone knows something," Smith's wife said. They believed his clothing and general appearance would not go unnoticed or unremembered.
The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department (LACSD) was leading the investigation. They had suggested that they had pings from Smith's cell phone after 10 p.m. the night he disappeared, although they did not make the specifics public. "He was bouncing around the Valley or, at least, his phone was," said LACSD Sgt. John O'Brien. "We are talking about after bars close." On May 8, a male body was found in the Angeles National Forest near the Angeles Crest Highway above La Cañada Flintridge, but it was not Smith's.
The Smiths and their friends had been looking in ravines in the area or other places where his car might have gone off the road, without success. A volunteer search of remote areas planned for the weekend of May 19–20 was called off due to the lack of "a specific area of defined interest" in which to search. Flyers were distributed and the LACSD had a special hotline number which, it said, received "lots of tips". The family had put up a blog dedicated to the search and was offering a $20,000 reward. Evan Smith had been using his Twitter feed to spread the word on the search as well.
A possible sighting of Smith subsequent to the disappearance was reported at the end of the month. David Brill of Madison, Wisconsin, who had been traveling to Southern California on business around the time Smith disappeared, told a TV station in his hometown that he had seen Smith with a woman at a restaurant in Morro Bay on May 7. The next morning he read the story online and identified Smith as the man. The waitress who served the man also believed him to be Smith, and said that he paid in cash and told her that he and his companion would be staying in town for a couple of days and then continuing north up the Pacific coast. The restaurant claimed to have a security camera tape but would not release it to the media.
On June 8, police, accompanied by a SWAT team, executed a search warrant at a Canoga Park home belonging to a couple identified as John and Chandrika Creech, in connection with the case. After five hours, they emerged with several boxes and a computer, and towed away a black Audi sport-utility vehicle. Although searches like this are unusual in a missing-persons case, and homicide detectives were reportedly among the investigators present, the LACSD emphasized that it was still a missing-persons case and no evidence of foul play had yet been discovered. A lawyer for the Creeches who spoke with reporters at the scene said it was the second search of the house in the past month, but refused to comment further. Later, it was reported that more than 20 search warrants had been issued so far and police had seized cellphones and other files from the Creech house.
Two weeks later, more details about why the Creeches' house might have been searched were reported. Los Angeles County Sheriff's Lt. Dave Dolson said Gavin Smith met Chandrika Creech while they were both in drug rehab, and that they were in a romantic relationship. After it had started in 2008, she had broken it off at the request of her husband John Creech, a convicted drug dealer who was facing new charges at the time of the search, had reportedly had no contact with Smith other than an email exchange in 2008.
Smith's family and friends spent the second weekend of July passing out fliers and putting up posters in Sylmar, the city's northernmost neighborhood. According to them, the detectives investigating Smith's disappearance said his last cellphone ping had come from the area. "The police have led us specifically to this area," she said to reporters.
Since the search of the Creeches, the LACSD had not made any more public moves related to the case. John Creech pleaded guilty to the drug charges and was sentenced to eight years in prison in September 2012. America's Most Wanted did a segment on the case in October.
Earlier that month, before the segment aired, Lisa Smith spoke at length about her life with Gavin in an interview with Britain's The Daily Mail. She said her husband had not only renewed his old affair with Chandrika Creech, but had begun a new one recently with a younger woman she identified as "Melanie", whom he'd met, like Creech, while being treated for prescription drug addiction. It had been the discovery of the latter affair that led her to throw him out of the house several weeks before his disappearance. She had not intended for the separation to be permanent, but, she said, "I couldn't cope with him cheating and I wanted to make it clear that he could never do that again.'
Confronted by his wife, Smith initially broke off the affair with Creech. In 2010 however, Smith and Creech resumed their relationship and had begun exchanging romantic messages. Smith's wife discovered the messages and, in an impulsive decision, drove her two sons to Creech’s home where they told John Creech of the affair. He initially indicated his intent to kill their Smith, but later relented, telling the sons, "... you just saved your father's life by coming here today." In 2012, when the romance rekindled yet again, Creech allegedly made good on his threat, stalking Chandrika Creech using a cell phone GPS tracking application to her point of rendezvous, whereupon Creech pummeled Smith to his death, temporarily ditched his car and body at an accomplice's garage near Porter Ranch after the killing, returning later to retrieve the body and tow Smith's car to secluded, clandestine location.
Smith had been living at his office until a coworker found out and let him live at her house, the one he had returned to and left the night of his disappearance. Lisa Smith had found out that Gavin, a profligate and a Lothario, had been funneling money from his pension plan and had spent most of his $30,000 bonus from Fox from the previous year on possibly setting Melanie and her children up with a place to live. Once Fox stopped paying his salary two months after his disappearance, Lisa Smith said was having difficulty paying the mortgage. In August, Fox cleaned out Smith's office, and sent anything that the police did not need for their investigation to the Smiths' home.
His sister Tara Addeo, and John Creech's lawyer, told The Hollywood Reporter that the LACSD's search of the Creech residence had not yielded anything of use. She had nevertheless come to believe that he had become the victim of a crime. "I know that Gavin would not hurt himself, and I have a hard time believing that Gavin would ever walk away from his sons," she said. "The only other alternative is that there would have been foul play." A month later Lisa Smith told the Reporter that she had reached a similar conclusion. "I just don't picture him walking in and saying, 'I'm sorry; I just needed a breather.' I'm prepared for the worst."
On January 23, 2013, a vehicle seized at an unrelated Granada Hills drug bust turned out to belong to Creech. It led investigators to Gavin's missing Mercedes, found a month later at a Simi Valley storage facility, also connected with Creech, whom police continued to describe as a person of interest.
In March 2013, a sheriff's statement said detectives were now investigating the case as a homicide, although Gavin's body had not been found. Officials also revealed that they believed they had identified the motive in the alleged crime. However, citing the ongoing investigation, they declined to elaborate on the possible motive or any other details of the case.
Discovery of body
On October 26, 2014, Smith's body was found in Palmdale, California. A group of hikers found a shallow grave containing a skull, some bones, and clothing in a rural area between Palmdale and Acton just outside the Angeles National Forest. Authorities announced the body's discovery 11 days later, after it had been positively identified as Smith.
The cause of death was not initially known, as the county coroner's office was working to establish it. Investigators said it might take some time to do so, if indeed they could. "It could be months, if ever, worst-case scenario," said a spokesman for the coroner. Nevertheless, the Los Angeles Times quoted anonymous sources as saying that investigators believe that Smith was killed at the direction of one person, by others with experience in violent crime.
At a press conference held the day the body's discovery was announced, investigators shared more information. Their theory was that Smith was killed in his car shortly after he disappeared. Based on that evidence, they had "confidently labeled Smith's death a homicide" after finding the car in 2013. They believed the cause of death would prove to be blunt force trauma; although they could not yet rule out gunshot wounds they did not believe that there would be any.
In January 2015, a little over three months after Smith's body was discovered, Creech, two years into an eight-year sentence, was rearrested and charged with his murder. The arraignment was postponed for a month. Creech's attorney called Smith's death a "tragic accident" and that his client was innocent of the murder charge. "There may have been a fight but I can tell you there was no criminal intent," said Alex Kessel.
In May of that year the prosecution released transcripts of testimony before the grand jury that indicted Creech on murder charges. According to witnesses, on the night of May 1 he borrowed a van and went to where Smith had parked his Mercedes with Chandrika Creech. Surprising them there, he beat Smith severely while Chandrika, who believed she would be next, escaped and screamed for help. Later Creech, who did not initially believe Smith had been fatally injured, drove Smith's car to Stan McQuay's home in Porter Ranch, where he and McQuay extracted Smith's body and disposed of him, wrapped in a bloodied sheet, buried in a shallow grave east of Acton in the Antelope Valley off Angeles Forest Highway. McQuay temporarily stored Smith's missing vehicle in his garage one week from the night of Smith's murder, affording Creech time sufficient to make clandestine arrangements for its long term concealment, parked in a car-sized room at a public storage facility just west of McQuay's Porter Ranch residence, in Simi Valley
- Soo, Youn (November 6, 2014). "Fox Exec Gavin Smith: Investigators Say They Know 'How and Why' He Was Slain". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved November 7, 2014.
- Norlander, Matt (May 7, 2012). "Gavin Smith, former UCLA player, father to current USC sophomore, is missing". CBS Sports. Retrieved May 17, 2012.
- Mizutani, Ron (May 10, 2012). "Former UH basketball star Gavin Smith missing". KHON-TV. Honolulu. Archived from the original on December 24, 2013. Retrieved May 17, 2012.
- "Missing Fox Exec Gavin Smith Declared Dead by Sheriff's Department". Variety. May 1, 2014. Retrieved May 6, 2014.
- "Remains of long-missing Fox movie exec Gavin Smith found". November 6, 2014. Retrieved November 6, 2014.
- Rocha, Veronica; Winton, Richard (January 29, 2015). "Convicted drug dealer charged in murder of Fox exec Gavin Smith". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved February 7, 2015.
- Lloyd, Jonathan; Lopez, Lolita (February 2, 2015). "Death of Fox Exec Gavin Smith a Tragic Accident: Attorney". KNBC-TV. Retrieved February 9, 2015.
- Panzar, Javier (May 11, 2016). "Details of Fox executive's slaying revealed in grand jury transcripts". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved December 28, 2016.
- Gerber, Marisa (July 3, 2017). "Man guilty of manslaughter of Fox executive who was beaten and buried in the desert". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved July 5, 2017.
- "Prep All-America". Pomona Progress-Bulletin. 30 March 1973. p. 24. Retrieved August 7, 2014 – via Newspapers.com.
- Miller, Daniel (May 10, 2012). "Body Found in Angeles National Forest Is Not Missing 20th Century Fox Executive". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved May 17, 2012.
- Vega, Cecilia (May 8, 2012). "Missing Hollywood Exec Gavin Smith's Family Pleads for Help". ABC News. Retrieved May 16, 2012.
- Miller, Daniel (May 11, 2012). "Gavin Smith Mystery: Details Emerge About the Fox Executive's Disappearance". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved May 17, 2012.
- Fernandez, Maria Elena; Pelisek, Christine (May 24, 2012). "The Personal Trials of Missing Fox Movie Executive Gavin Smith". The Daily Beast. Retrieved May 29, 2012.
- "Sources: Missing Fox Exec Gavin Smith Had Affair With Woman Whose House Was Searched by Police". Eonline.com. 2012-06-21. Retrieved 2016-09-30.
- Saperstein, Pat; Stedman, Alex (2014-11-05). "UPDATED: Fox Exec Gavin Smith's Body Found". Variety. Retrieved 2016-09-30.
- Giordano, Jackie. "Timeline: Fox Executive Gavin Smith Case". Nbclosangeles.com. Retrieved 2016-09-30.
- "Something 'just not right' in case of missing Fox movie executive Gavin Smith, detective says". Fox News. 2012-08-02. Retrieved 2016-09-30.
- Romero, Dennis (May 8, 2012). "Gavin Smith, Missing Fox Executive, Gets Twitter Campaign From Son Evan, USC Basketball Player". LA Weekly. Retrieved May 17, 2012.
- Lee, Ken (March 22, 2013). "Missing Hollywood Executive: Was He Murdered in a Love Triangle?". People. Retrieved November 7, 2014.
- "Mystery deepens in disappearance of Hollywood exec Gavin Smith". The Los Angeles Times. May 10, 2012. Retrieved May 17, 2012.
- Couch, Aaron (May 16, 2012). "Gavin Smith Family Calls Off Weekend Search for Missing Fox Executive". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved May 17, 2012.
- "Find Gavin Smith". wordpress.com. May 16, 2012. Archived from the original on May 16, 2012. Retrieved May 17, 2012.
- Curry, Colleen (May 25, 2012). "Missing LA Exec Gavin Smith Possibly Spotted With Woman in Restaurant". ABC News. Retrieved May 29, 2012.
- Leu, Melissa; Blankstein, Andrew (June 10, 2012). "Home searched in hunt for missing movie executive". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved June 21, 2012.
- Machado, Baker; Bromley, Melanie (June 21, 2012). "Sources: Missing Fox Exec Gavin Smith Had Affair With Woman Whose House Was Searched by Police". E!Online. Retrieved June 21, 2012.
- Kandel, Jason (2013-03-15). "Missing Fox Executive in Relationship With Wife of "Person of Interest:" Sheriff". Nbclosangeles.com. Retrieved 2016-09-30.
- "Missing Fox executive Gavin Smith's family canvasses Sylmar area". Los Angeles Times. July 8, 2012. Retrieved July 17, 2012.
- Ebright, Olsen; Healy, Patrick (August 29, 2012). "Sentencing Delayed for Drug Dealer Whose Home Was Searched in Gavin Smith Case". KNBC-TV. Retrieved September 30, 2012.
- "Gavin Smith case: Drug deal not a likely factor". LA Times. March 14, 2013. Retrieved July 9, 2013.
- Miller, Daniel (September 19, 2012). "'America's Most Wanted' to Air Feature on Missing Fox Exec Gavin Smith". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved September 30, 2012.
- Witheridge, Annette (October 5, 2012). "Real-life Hollywood whodunit: Wife of movie executive who vanished five months ago reveals his sordid double life of affairs and drugs ... and how she fears he's been murdered". The Daily Mail. Retrieved October 7, 2012.
- "Trial begins in murder of Hollywood executive found dead in AV". The AV Times. June 15, 2017. Retrieved June 15, 2017. External link in
- Miller, Daniel (September 9, 2012). "Missing Fox Exec Gavin Smith's Sister: 'Where Could He Possibly Be?'". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved November 21, 2012.
- Schillaci, Sophie (October 11, 2012). "Wife of Missing Fox Exec Gavin Smith Acknowledges Extramarital Affairs, Suspects Foul Play". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved November 21, 2012.
- Kovacik, Robert; French, Bill (January 24, 2013). "New Lead in Case of Missing Fox Exec Gavin Smith". KNBC. Retrieved March 15, 2013.
- "Missing Fox executive Gavin Smith's car found; homicide suspected". The Los Angeles Times. March 14, 2013. Retrieved March 14, 2013.
- Blankstein, Mather, and Winton (March 14, 2013). "Police say they have motive for alleged killing of Gavin Smith". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved September 2, 2014.
- Karimi, Faith; Nichols, JR (November 6, 2014). "Fox executive's body found more than two years after he vanished". CNN.com. Retrieved November 6, 2014.
- Bloom, Tracy; Burrous, Chris (November 6, 2014). "Body of Movie Executive Gavin Smith Found, ID'd 2 Years After Mysterious Disappearance". KTLA. Retrieved November 6, 2014.
- Winton1, Richard; Serna, Joseph (November 6, 2014). "Fox exec Gavin Smith's killing ordered by one, carried out by others: cops". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved November 6, 2014.
- Gerber, Marissa (June 15, 2017). "A lurid tale of sex, deceit and brutality as trial begins in the slaying of Fox executive". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved June 15, 2017.