Presidency of Calvin Coolidge

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Presidency of Calvin Coolidge
Ccoolidge.jpeg
In office
August 2, 1923 – March 4, 1929
Preceded by Harding presidency
Succeeded by Hoover presidency
Seat White House, Washington, D.C.
Political party Republican

The presidency of Calvin Coolidge began on August 2, 1923, when Calvin Coolidge became President of the United States upon the sudden death of Warren G. Harding, and ended on March 4, 1929. A member of the Republican Party, Coolidge had been Vice President of the United States for 2 years, 151 days when he became the 30th President of the United States. Elected to a full four–year term in 1924, Coolidge gained a reputation as a small-government conservative. Coolidge was succeeded by Secretary of Commerce Herbert Hoover after the 1928 presidential election.

Coolidge adeptly handled the aftermath of several Harding administration scandals, and by the end of 1924 he had dismissed most officials implicated in the scandals, he presided over a strong economy and sought to shrink the regulatory role of the federal government. Along with Secretary of the Treasury Andrew Mellon, Coolidge won the passage of three major tax cuts. Using powers delegated to him by the 1922 Fordney–McCumber Tariff, Coolidge kept tariff rates high in order to protect American manufacturing. He blocked passage of the McNary–Haugen Farm Relief Bill, which would have involved the federal government in the persistent farm crisis that affected many rural communities, the strong economy combined with restrained government spending to produce consistent government surpluses, and total federal debt shrank by one quarter during Coolidge's presidency. Coolidge also signed the Immigration Act of 1924, which greatly restricted immigration into the United States; in foreign policy, Coolidge continued to keep the United States out of the League of Nations, but he engaged with foreign leaders and sponsored the Kellogg–Briand Pact of 1928.

Coolidge was greatly admired during his time in office, and he surprised many by declining to seek another term. Public opinion on Coolidge soured shortly after he left office as the nation plunged into the Great Depression. Many linked the nation's economic collapse to Coolidge's policy decisions, which did nothing to discourage the wild speculation that was going on and rendered so many vulnerable to economic ruin. Though his reputation underwent a renaissance during the Ronald Reagan administration, modern assessments of Coolidge's presidency are divided. He is adulated among advocates of smaller government and laissez-faire; supporters of an active central government generally view him less favorably, while both sides praise his support of racial equality.[1]

Accession[edit]

Coolidge signing the Immigration Act and some appropriation bills. General John J. Pershing looks on.

On August 2, 1923, President Harding died unexpectedly in San Francisco while on a speaking tour of the western United States. Vice President Coolidge was in Vermont visiting his family home, which had neither electricity nor a telephone, when he received word by messenger of Harding's death,[2] he dressed, said a prayer, and came downstairs to greet the reporters who had assembled.[2] His father, a notary public, administered the oath of office in the family's parlor by the light of a kerosene lamp at 2:47 a.m. on August 3, 1923; President Coolidge then went back to bed. He returned to Washington the next day, and was sworn in again by Justice Adolph A. Hoehling Jr. of the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia, to forestall any questions about the authority of a notary public to administer the presidential oath.[3]

Coolidge addressed Congress when it reconvened on December 6, 1923, giving a speech that supported many of Harding's policies, including Harding's formal budgeting process and the enforcement of immigration restrictions.[4] Coolidge's speech was the first presidential speech to be broadcast over the radio,[5] the Washington Naval Treaty, which had been negotiated in 1921 and 1922, became effective just one month into Coolidge's term, and was generally well received in the country.[6]

Administration[edit]

The Coolidge Cabinet
Office Name Term
President Calvin Coolidge1923–1929
Vice President none1923–1925
Charles G. Dawes1925–1929
Secretary of State Charles Evans Hughes1923–1925
Frank B. Kellogg1925–1929
Secretary of Treasury Andrew Mellon1923–1929
Secretary of War John W. Weeks1923–1925
Dwight F. Davis1925–1929
Attorney General Harry M. Daugherty1923–1924
Harlan F. Stone1924–1925
John G. Sargent1925–1929
Postmaster General Harry S. New1923–1929
Secretary of the Navy Edwin Denby1923–1924
Curtis D. Wilbur1924–1929
Secretary of the Interior Hubert Work1923–1928
Roy O. West1928–1929
Secretary of Agriculture Henry C. Wallace1923–1924
Howard M. Gore1924–1925
William M. Jardine1925–1929
Secretary of Commerce Herbert Hoover1923–1928
William F. Whiting1928–1929
Secretary of Labor James J. Davis1923–1929

Although a few of Harding's cabinet appointees were scandal-tarred, Coolidge initially retained all of them, out of an ardent conviction that as successor to a deceased elected president he was obligated to retain Harding's counselors and policies until the next election, he kept Harding's able speechwriter Judson T. Welliver; Stuart Crawford replaced Welliver in November 1925.[7] Coolidge appointed C. Bascom Slemp, a Virginia Congressman and experienced federal politician, to work jointly with Edward T. Clark, a Massachusetts Republican organizer whom he retained from his vice-presidential staff, as Secretaries to the President (a position equivalent to the modern White House Chief of Staff).[6]

Perhaps the most powerful person in Coolidge's Cabinet was Secretary of the Treasury Andrew Mellon, who controlled the administration's financial policies and was regarded by many, including House Minority Leader John Nance Garner, as more powerful than Coolidge himself.[8] Secretary of Commerce Herbert Hoover also held a prominent place in Coolidge's Cabinet, in part because Coolidge found value in Hoover's ability to win positive publicity with his pro-business proposals.[9] Secretary of State Charles Evans Hughes directed Coolidge's foreign policy until he resigned in 1925 following Coolidge's re-election, he was replaced by Frank B. Kellogg, who had previously served as a Senator and as the ambassador to Great Britain. Coolidge made two other appointments following his re-election, with William M. Jardine taking the position of Secretary of Agriculture and John G. Sargent becoming Attorney General.[10] Coolidge appointed Sargent only after the Senate rejected his first choice, Charles B. Warren. Warren was the first cabinet nominee to be rejected by the Senate since 1868.[11] Coolidge did not have a vice president during his first term, but Charles Dawes became vice president during Coolidge's second term, and Dawes and Coolidge clashed over farm policy and other issues.[12]

Judicial appointments[edit]

Coolidge appointed one justice to the Supreme Court of the United States, Harlan Fiske Stone in 1925. Stone was Coolidge's fellow Amherst alumnus, a Wall Street lawyer and conservative Republican. Stone was serving as dean of Columbia Law School when Coolidge appointed him to be attorney general in 1924 to restore the reputation tarnished by Harding's Attorney General, Harry M. Daugherty.[13] Stone proved to be a firm believer in judicial restraint and was regarded as one of the court's three liberal justices who would often vote to uphold New Deal legislation.[14] President Franklin D. Roosevelt later appointed Stone to be chief justice, a position Stone held until his death in 1946.[15]

Coolidge nominated 17 judges to the United States Courts of Appeals, and 61 judges to the United States district courts. He appointed Genevieve R. Cline to the United States Customs Court, and Cline became the first woman to serve in the federal judiciary.[16] Coolidge also signed the Judiciary Act of 1925 into law, allowing the Supreme Court more discretion over its workload.

Domestic policy[edit]

Harding administration scandals[edit]

In the waning days of Harding's administration, several scandals had begun to emerge into public view. Though Coolidge was not implicated in any corrupt dealings, he dealt with the fallout of the scandals in the early days of his presidency, the Teapot Dome Scandal tainted the careers of former Secretary of the Interior Albert B. Fall (who had resigned in March 1923) and Secretary of the Navy Edwin Denby, and additional scandals implicated Attorney General Harry M. Daugherty and Charles R. Forbes, the former Director of the Veterans Bureau. A bipartisan Senate investigation led by Thomas J. Walsh and Robert LaFolette began just weeks into Coolidge's presidency. As the investigation uncovered further misconduct, Coolidge appointed Atlee Pomerene and Owen Roberts as special prosecutors, but he remained personally unconvinced as to the guilt of Harding's appointees. Despite congressional pressure, he refused to dismiss Denby, who instead resigned of his own accord in March 1924, that same month, after Daugherty refused to resign, Coolidge fired him. Coolidge also replaced the Director of the Bureau of Investigation, William J. Burns, with J. Edgar Hoover. The investigation by Pomerene and Roberts, combined with the departure of the scandal-tarred Harding appointees, served to disassociate Coolidge from the Harding administration's misdeeds.[17] By May 1924, Harding's scandals had largely receded from public attention, though a separate scandal involving former Postmaster General Will H. Hays would briefly garner headlines in 1928.[18]

Economy and regulation[edit]

it is probable that a press which maintains an intimate touch with the business currents of the nation is likely to be more reliable than it would be if it were a stranger to these influences. After all, the chief business of the American people is business. They are profoundly concerned with buying, selling, investing and prospering in the world. (emphasis added)
President Calvin Coolidge's address to the American Society of Newspaper Editors, Washington D.C., January 25, 1925.[19]

During Coolidge's presidency, the United States experienced a period of rapid economic growth known as the "Roaring Twenties."[20] The country's gross domestic product rose from $85.2 billion in 1924 to $101.4 in 1929, while the unemployment rate was generally low throughout Coolidge's tenure.[21] According to Nathan Miller, "the postwar years ushered in an age of consumerism with a broader base of participation than had ever existed before in America or anywhere else."[22] The number of automobiles in the United States increased from 7 million in 1919 to 23 million in 1929, while the percentage of households with electricity rose from 16 percent in 1912 to 60 percent in the mid-1920s.[20]

The regulatory state under Coolidge was, as one biographer described it, "thin to the point of invisibility."[23] Coolidge believed that promoting the interests of manufacturers was good for society as a whole, and he sought to reduce taxes and regulations on businesses while imposing tariffs to protect those interests against foreign competition.[24] Coolidge demonstrated his disdain for regulation by appointing commissioners to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Interstate Commerce Commission who did little to restrict the activities of businesses under their jurisdiction.[25] Under leadership of Chairman William E. Humphrey, a Coolidge appointee, the FTC largely stopped prosecuting anti-trust cases, allowing companies like Alcoa to dominate entire industries.[26] Coolidge also avoided interfering with the workings of the Federal Reserve, which kept interest rates low and allowed for the expansion of margin trading in the stock market,[27] the 1922 Fordney–McCumber Tariff allowed the president some leeway in determining tariff rates, and Coolidge used his power to raise the already-high rates set by Fordney–McCumber.[28] He also staffed the United States Tariff Commission, a board that advised the president on tariff rates, with businessmen who favored high tariffs.[29]

Secretary of Commerce Hoover energetically used government auspices to promote business efficiency and develop new industries like air travel and radio.[30] Between 1923 and 1929, the number of families with radios grew from 300,000 to 10 million, and during the early-to-mid 1920s Hoover's Commerce Department attempted to regulate wavelengths through voluntary cooperation,[31] the Radio Act of 1927 established the Federal Radio Commission under the auspices of the Commerce Department, and the commission granted numerous licenses to large, commercial radio stations.[32] At Hoover's request, Congress also passed the Air Commerce Act, which granted the Commerce Department the authority to regulate air travel,[33] the Coolidge administration provided matching funds for roads under the authorization of the Federal Aid Highway Act of 1921, and the number of automobiles in the United States grew from 9.3 million in 1921 to 26.7 million in 1929.[34] The total mileage of highways doubled in the 1920s, and the administration helped establish the United States Numbered Highway System, which provided for orderly designation of highways and uniform signage on those highways.[35] Hoover was a strong proponent of cooperation between government and business, and he organized numerous conferences of intellectuals and businessmen which made various recommendations. Relatively few reforms were passed, but the proposals created the image of an active administration.[36]

Some have labeled Coolidge as an adherent of the laissez-faire ideology, which some critics claim led to the Great Depression.[37] Historian Robert Sobel argues instead that Coolidge's belief in federalism guided his economic policy, writing, "as Governor of Massachusetts, Coolidge supported wages and hours legislation, opposed child labor, imposed economic controls during World War I, favored safety measures in factories, and even worker representation on corporate boards...such matters were considered the responsibilities of state and local governments."[38][39] Historian David Greenberg argues that Coolidge's economic policies, designed primarily to bolster American industry, are best described as Hamiltonian rather than laissez-faire.[24]

Taxation and government spending[edit]

Coolidge took office in the aftermath of World War I, during which the United States had raised taxes to unprecedented rates.[40] Coolidge's taxation policy was that of Treasury Secretary Mellon, the ideal that "scientific taxation"—lower taxes—actually increase rather than decrease government receipts.[41] Mellon believed that the benefits of lower taxes on the rich would "trickle down" to society as whole by encouraging increased investment, the Revenue Act of 1921, which had been proposed by Mellon, had reduced the top marginal tax rate from 71% to 58%, and Mellon sought to further reduce rates and abolish other taxes during Coolidge's presidency.[42]

Coolidge spent early 1924 opposing the World War Adjusted Compensation Act or "Bonus Bill," which he believed would be a fiscally irresponsible expenditure.[43] With a budget surplus, many legislators wanted to reward the veterans of World War I with extra compensation, arguing that the soldiers had been paid poorly during the war. Coolidge and Mellon preferred to use the budget surplus to cut taxes, and they did not believe that the country could pass both bills and maintain a balanced budget. However, the bill gained wide support and was endorsed by several prominent Republicans, including Henry Cabot Lodge and Charles Curtis. Congress overrode Coolidge's veto of the Bonus Bill, handing the president a defeat in his first major legislative battle.[44]

With his legislative priorities in jeopardy following the debate over the Bonus Bill, Coolidge backed off on his goal of lowering the top tax rate down to 25%,[45] after much legislative haggling, Congress passed the Revenue Act of 1924, which reduced income tax rates and eliminated all income taxation for some two million people.[46] The act reduced the top marginal tax rate from 58% to 46%, but increased the estate tax and bolstered it with a new gift tax,[47] after his re-election in 1924, Coolidge sought further tax reductions,[48] and Congress cut taxes with the Revenue Acts of 1926 and 1928. Congress abolished the gift tax in 1926, but Mellon was unable to win repeal of the estate tax, which had been established by the Revenue Act of 1916; in addition to cutting top rates, the tax acts also increased the amount of income exempt from taxation, and by 1928 only 2% of taxpayers paid any federal income tax. By 1930, one-third of federal revenue came from income taxes, one-third from corporate taxes, and most of the remaining third came from the tariff and excise taxes on tobacco.[49]

Coolidge inherited a budget surplus of $700 million, but also a federal debt of $22.3 billion, with most of that debt having been accumulated in World War I.[50] Federal spending remained flat during Coolidge's administration, contributing to the retirement of about one-fourth of the federal debt. Coolidge would be the last president to significantly reduce federal debt until Bill Clinton's tenure in the 1990s, although intervening presidents presided over a reduction of debt in proportion to the country's gross domestic product.[51]

Immigration[edit]

A strong nativist movement had arisen in the years prior to Coolidge's presidency,[52] with hostility focused on immigrants from Eastern Europe, Southeastern Europe, and, especially on the West Coast, East Asia.[53] Prior to Coolidge's presidency, Congress had passed the Immigration Act of 1917, which imposed a literacy test on immigrants, as well as the Emergency Quota Act of 1921, the latter act had put a temporary cap on the number of immigrants accepted into the country.[52] A constituent writing to Senator William Borah reflected the opinion of many who favored immigration restriction, stating "immigration should be completely stopped for at least one generation until we can assimilate and Americanize the millions who are in our midst."[54] In the years after the passage of the Emergency Quota Act, members of Congress debated the substance of a permanent immigration bill. Most leaders of both parties favored a permanent bill that would greatly restrict immigration, with the major exception being Al Smith and other urban Democrats.[55] Business leaders had previously favored unlimited immigration to the United States, but mechanization and the entrance of women into the labor force, and the migration of Southern blacks into the North all reduced the demand for foreign-born labor.[56]

Coolidge endorsed an extension of the cap on immigration in his 1923 State of the Union, but his administration was less supportive of the continuation of the National Origins Formula, which effectively restricted immigration from countries outside of Northwestern Europe. Secretary of State Hughes strongly opposed the quotas, particularly the total ban on Japanese immigration, which violated the Gentlemen's Agreement of 1907 with Japan, despite his own reservations, Coolidge choose to sign the restrictive Immigration Act of 1924.[52] The Emergency Quota Act had limited annual immigration from any given country to 3% of the immigrant population from that country living in the United States in 1920; the Immigration Act of 1924 changed this to 2% of the immigrant population from a given country living in the United States in 1890.[57] As the Immigration Act of 1924 remained in force until the passage of the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965, it greatly affected the demographics of immigration for several decades.[52]

Opposition to farm subsidies[edit]

Coolidge with his vice president, Charles G. Dawes

Perhaps the most contentious issue of Coolidge's presidency was relief for farmers, whose incomes had collapsed after World War I,[58] after the end of the Civil War, American farmers had been able to export cotton, grain, and other crops to Britain and other regions of the world, but American farmers faced increasing competition on world markets. Many farmers were unable to sell their crops, in a phenomenon known as overproduction, this overproduction was exacerbated by the introduction of tractors, which increased the productivity of individual farmers and opened up farmland that had previously been devoted to growing crops used to feed farm animals.[59] Overproduction led to an ongoing farm crisis that proved devastating to many rural areas,[60] the farm crisis was a major political issue throughout the 1920s as farmers remained a powerful voting bloc despite the rising tide of urbanization.[61]

Secretary of Agriculture Wallace floated the possibility of restricting the number of acres that each farmer would be allowed to farm, but the unpopularity of this proposal among farmers made it politically infeasible,[62] after the 1924 elections, the Coolidge administration introduced an agricultural plan that emphasized agricultural cooperatives to help control prices, but it found little favor among farmers.[63] The farm bloc instead coalesced behind the ideas of George Peek, whose proposals to raise farm prices inspired the McNary–Haugen Farm Relief Bill.[64] McNary–Haugen proposed the establishment of a federal farm board that would purchase surplus production in high-yield years and hold it (when feasible) for later sale or sell it abroad,[65] the key to the plan was that it would allow American farmers to dump products abroad despite the competitive disadvantages posed by tariffs.[66] The government would lose money in selling the crops abroad, but would recoup some of that loss through fees on farmers who benefited from the program.[66] Proponents of the bill argued that the program was little different from protective tariffs, which they argued were used to disproprotionately benefit industrial concerns.[67] Coolidge opposed McNary-Haugen, declaring that agriculture must stand "on an independent business basis," and said that "government control cannot be divorced from political control."[65] Secretary Mellon wrote a letter denouncing the McNary-Haugen measure as unsound and likely to cause inflation,[68] the first and second incarnations of the McNary-Haugen bill were defeated in 1924 and 1925, but the bill remained popular as the farm crisis continued.[69]

A decline in cotton prices in 1925 raised the possibility that Southern congressmen would join with Western congressmen in supporting a major agricultural bill. Seeking to prevent the creation of a major new government program, Coolidge sought to peel away potential supporters of McNary-Haugen and mobilized businessmen and other groups in opposition to the bill,[70] he also favored passage of the Curtis-Crisp Act, which would have created a federal board to lend money to farm co-operatives in times of surplus; the bill did not pass.[68] In February 1927, Congress took up the McNary-Haugen bill again, this time narrowly passing it, and Coolidge vetoed it,[71] the bill, which bore the name of Republicans members of Congress, had passed the Senate with the help of Coolidge's own vice president.[12] In his veto message, Coolidge expressed the belief that the bill would do nothing to help farmers, benefiting only exporters and expanding the federal bureaucracy.[72] Congress did not override the veto, but it passed the bill again in May 1928 by an increased majority; again, Coolidge vetoed it.[71] "Farmers never have made much money," said Coolidge, the Vermont farmer's son. "I do not believe we can do much about it."[73] Secretary Jardine developed his own plan to address the farm crisis that established a Federal Farm Board, and his plan eventually would form the basis of the Agricultural Marketing Act of 1929, which was passed in the first year of the Hoover administration.[74]

Great Mississippi Flood[edit]

Coolidge has often been criticized for his actions during the Great Mississippi Flood of 1927, the worst natural disaster to hit the Gulf Coast until Hurricane Katrina in 2005.[75] He initially declined the request of six governors to provide federal assistance and visit the site of the flooding,[76] although he did eventually name Secretary Hoover to a head a federal commission in charge of flood relief, scholars argue that Coolidge overall showed a lack of interest in federal flood control.[75] Coolidge did not believe that personally visiting the region after the floods would accomplish anything, and that it would be seen as mere political grandstanding, he also did not want to incur the federal spending that flood control would require; he believed property owners should bear much of the cost.[77] Congress, meanwhile, favored a bill that would place the federal government completely in charge of flood mitigation.[78] When Congress passed a compromise measure in 1928, Coolidge declined to take credit for it and signed the Flood Control Act of 1928 in private on May 15.[79]

Labor[edit]

Union membership declined during the 1920s, partly because of consistently rising wages and the declining length of the average work week. Compared to previous years, Coolidge's tenure saw relatively few strikes, and the only major labor disturbance Coolidge faced was the 1923 anthracite coal strike.[80] Coolidge generally avoided labor issues, leaving the administration's response to unrest in the mines to Hoover. Hoover produced the Jacksonville agreement, a voluntary compact between miners and mining companies, but the agreement had little effect,[81] during the 1920s, the conservative Taft Court issued several holdings that damaged labor unions, and allowing lower courts to use injunctions to end strikes. The court was also hostile to federal regulations designed to ensure minimal working conditions, and it declared minimum wage laws unconstitutional in the 1923 case of Adkins v. Children's Hospital.[82]

After the Supreme Court twice—in Hammer v. Dagenhart (1918) and Bailey v. Drexel Furniture (1922)—ruled that federal laws regulating and taxing goods produced by employees under the ages of 14 and 16 were unconstitutional, Congress, on June 2, 1924, approved an amendment to the United States Constitution that would that would specifically authorize Congress to regulate "labor of persons under eighteen years of age", and submitted it to the state legislatures for ratification.[83] Coolidge expressed support for the amendment in his first State of the Union,[84] the amendment, commonly known as the Child Labor Amendment, was never ratified by the requisite number of states, and, as there was no time limit set for its ratification, is still pending before the states.[85] However, the Supreme Court overturned Hammer v. Dagenhart in the 1941 case of United States v. Darby Lumber Co., making the Child Labor Amendment a moot issue.[86]

Other issues[edit]

The Eighteenth Amendment, ratified in 1920, had effectively established the prohibition of alcoholic beverages in the United States, and the Volstead Act had established penalties for violating the amendment.[87] Coolidge personally opposed Prohibition, but sought to enforce federal law and refrained from serving liquor in the White House.[88] Though Congress had established the Bureau of Prohibition to enforce the Volstead Act, federal enforcement of Prohibition was lax, as most states left enforcement of Prohibition to the federal government, the illegal production of alcoholic beverages flourished.[89] Leaders of organized crime like Arnold Rothstein and Al Capone arranged for the importation of alcohol from Canada and other locations, and the profitability of bootlegging contributed to the rising influence of organized crime.[90] Nonetheless, alcohol consumption fell dramatically during the 1920s, in part due to the high price of alcoholic drinks.[91]

Coolidge spoke in favor of the civil rights of African-Americans, saying in his first State of the Union address that their rights were "just as sacred as those of any other citizen" under the U.S. Constitution and that it was a "public and a private duty to protect those rights."[92][93] He appointed no known members of the Ku Klux Klan to office; indeed, the Klan lost most of its influence during his term.[94] He also repeatedly called for laws to prohibit lynching, saying in his 1923 State of the Union address that it was a "hideous crime" of which African-Americans were "by no means the sole sufferers" but made up the "majority of the victims."[93] However, most congressional attempts to pass this legislation were filibustered by Southern Democrats.[95] Coolidge did not emphasize the appointment of African-Americans to federal positions, and he did not appoint any prominent blacks during his tenure as president.[96]

Osage men with Coolidge after he signed the bill granting Native Americans U.S. citizenship.

On June 2, 1924, Coolidge signed the Indian Citizenship Act, which granted U.S. citizenship to all American Indians, while permitting them to retain tribal land and cultural rights. By that time, two-thirds of Native Americans were already citizens, having gained citizenship through marriage, military service, or the land allotments that had earlier taken place.[97][98][99] The act was unclear on whether the federal government or the tribal leaders retained tribal sovereignty.[100] Coolidge also appointed the Committee of One Hundred, a reform panel to examine federal institutions and programs dealing with Indian nations, this committee recommended that the government conduct an in-depth investigation into reservation life (health, education, economics, justice, civil rights, etc.). This was commissioned through the Department of Interior and conducted by the Brookings Institution, resulting in the groundbreaking Meriam Report of 1928.[citation needed]

Foreign policy[edit]

Although not an isolationist, Coolidge was reluctant to enter into foreign alliances,[101] he considered the 1920 Republican victory as a rejection of the Wilsonian position that the United States should join the League of Nations.[102] While not completely opposed to the idea, Coolidge believed the League, as then constituted, did not serve American interests, and he did not advocate membership,[102] he spoke in favor of the United States joining the Permanent Court of International Justice (World Court), provided that the nation would not be bound by advisory decisions.[103] In 1926, the Senate eventually approved joining the Court (with reservations),[104] the League of Nations accepted the reservations, but it suggested some modifications of its own.[105] As the Senate failed to act on the modifications, the United States never joined the World Court.[105]

Europe[edit]

In the aftermath of World War I, several European nations struggled with debt, including billions of dollars owed to the United States, these European nations were owed an enormous sum from Germany in the form of World War I reparations, and the German economy buckled under the weight of these reparations. Coolidge rejected calls to forgive Europe's debt or lower tariffs on European goods, but the Occupation of the Ruhr in 1923 stirred him to action, on Secretary of State Hughes's initiative, Coolidge appointed Charles Dawes to lead an international commission to reach an agreement on Germany's reparations. The resulting Dawes Plan provided for a withdrawal restructuring of the German debt, and the United States loaned money to Germany to help it repay its debt other countries, the Dawes Plan led to a boom in the German economy and a sentiment of international cooperation.[106]

Building on the success of the Dawes Plan, U.S. ambassador Alanson B. Houghton helped convene the Locarno Conference in October 1925. The conference was designed to ease tensions between Germany and France, the latter of which feared a German rearmament; in the Locarno Treaties, France, Belgium, and Germany each agreed to respect the borders established by the Treaty of Versailles and pledged not to attack each other. Germany also agreed to arbitrate its eastern boundaries with the states created in the Treaty of Versailles.[107]

Coolidge's primary foreign policy initiative was the Kellogg–Briand Pact of 1928, named for Secretary of State Kellogg and French foreign minister Aristide Briand, the treaty, ratified in 1929, committed signatories—the United States, the United Kingdom, France, Germany, Italy, and Japan—to "renounce war, as an instrument of national policy in their relations with one another."[108] The treaty did not achieve its intended result—the outlawry of war—but it did provide the founding principle for international law after World War II.[109] Coolidge's policy of international disarmament allowed the administration to decrease military spending, a part of Coolidge's broader policy of decreasing government spending.[110] Coolidge also favored an extension of the Washington Naval Treaty to cover cruisers, but the U.S., Britain, and Japan were unable to come to an agreement at the Geneva Naval Conference.[111]

Latin America[edit]

After the Mexican Revolution, the U.S. had refused to recognize the government of Álvaro Obregón, one of the revolution's leaders. Secretary of State Hughes had worked with Mexico to normalize relations during the Harding administration, and President Coolidge recognized the Mexican government in 1923. To help Obregón defeat a rebellion, Coolidge also lifted an embargo on Mexico and encouraged U.S. banks to loan to the Mexican government. In 1924, Plutarco Elías Calles took office as President of Mexico, and Calles sought to limit American property claims and take control of the holdings of the Catholic church. However, Ambassador Dwight Morrow convinced Calles to allow Americans to retain their rights to property purchased before 1917, and Mexico and the United States enjoyed good relations for the remainder of Coolidge's presidency,[112] with the aid of a Catholic priest from the U.S., Morrow also helped bring an end to the Cristero War, a Catholic revolt against Calles's government.[113]

The United States' occupation of Nicaragua and Haiti continued under his administration, but Coolidge withdrew American troops from the Dominican Republic in 1924.[114] The U.S. established a domestic constabulary in the Dominican Republic to promote internal order without the need for U.S. intervention, but the constabulary's leader, Rafael Trujillo, eventually seized power.[115] Coolidge led the U.S. delegation to the Sixth International Conference of American States, January 15–17, 1928, in Havana, Cuba. This was the only international trip Coolidge made during his presidency.[116] There, he extended an olive branch to Latin American leaders embittered over America's interventionist policies in Central America and the Caribbean.[117] For 88 years he was the only sitting president to have visited Cuba, until Barack Obama did so in 2016.[118]

Under the leadership of economist Edwin W. Kemmerer, the U.S. extended its influence in Latin America through financial advisers. With the support of the State Department, Kemmerer negotiated agreements with Colombia, Chile, and other countries in which the countries received loans and agreed to follow the advice of U.S. financial advisers. These "Kemmerized" countries received substantial investments from the U.S. and became increasingly dependent on trade with the U.S. While the countries enjoyed good economic conditions in the 1920s, many would struggle in the 1930s.[119]

East Asia[edit]

Relations with Japan had warmed with the signing of the Washington Naval Treaty, which had delineated territorial possessions in the Pacific Ocean. Ties between the two countries were further boosted by U.S. aid in the aftermath of the 1923 Great Kantō earthquake, which killed as many as 200,000 Japanese and left another 2 million homeless. However, relations soured with the passage of the Immigration Act of 1924, which banned immigration from Japan to the United States. U.S. officials encouraged Japan to protest the ban while the legislation was drafted, but Japanese threats backfired as supporters of the legislation used the threats to galvanize opposition to Japanese immigration. The immigration legislation sparked a major backlash in Japan, strengthening the position of those in Japan who favored expansionism over cooperation with Western powers.[53]

The Coolidge administration at first avoided engagement with the Republic of China, which was led by Sun Yat-sen and his successor, Chiang Kai-shek, the administration protested the Northern Expedition when it resulted in attacks on foreigners, and refused to consider renegotiating treaties reached with China when it had been under the rule of the Qing dynasty. In 1927, Chiang purged his government of Communists and began to seek U.S. support. Seeking closer relations with China, Secretary of State Kellogg agreed to grant tariff autonomy, meaning that China would have the right to set import duties on American goods.[120]

Elections[edit]

Election of 1924[edit]

The nation initially did not know what to make of Coolidge, who had maintained a low profile in the Harding administration; many had even expected him to be replaced on the ballot in 1924.[121] The 1923 United Mine Workers coal strike presented an immediate challenge to Coolidge, who avoided attempting to personally end the strike but convened the United States Coal Commission under the advice of Secretary of Commerce Herbert Hoover. Pennsylvania Governor Gifford Pinchot, a progressive Republican and potential rival for the 1924 presidential nomination, quickly settled the strike with little input from the federal government. Pinchot's settlement of the strike backfired, as he took the blame for rising coal prices, and Coolidge quickly consolidated his power among Republican elites.[122] Other potential opponents, like Governor Frank Lowden of Illinois and General Leonard Wood, failed to generate support for a challenge to Coolidge. Automobile magnate Henry Ford also loomed as a potential candidate, but Ford endorsed Coolidge for president in December 1923.[123]

The Republican Convention was held on June 10–12, 1924, in Cleveland, Ohio; Coolidge was nominated on the first ballot.[124] Coolidge's nomination made him the second unelected president to win his party's nomination for another term, after Theodore Roosevelt.[125] Prior to the convention, Coolidge courted progressive Senator William Borah to join the ticket, but Borah refused to relinquish his Senate seat.[126] Republicans then nominated Lowden for vice president on the second ballot, but he declined the nomination. Former Brigadier General Charles G. Dawes was nominated on the third ballot, and Dawes agreed to be placed on the Republican ticket.[124]

The Democrats held their convention the next month in New York City. Former Treasury Secretary William Gibbs McAdoo had been regarded by many as the front-runner for the Democratic presidential nomination, but his candidacy was damaged by his connection to the Teapot Dome Scandal. Nonetheless, he entered the convention as one of the two strongest candidates, alongside Governor Al Smith of New York.[127] Smith and McAdoo epitomized the divide in the Democratic Party; Smith drew support from Northeastern cities, while McAdoo's base was in the rural South and West.[128] The convention deadlocked over the presidential nominee, and after 103 ballots, the delegates finally agreed on a compromise candidate, John W. Davis. The Democrats' hopes were buoyed when Robert LaFolette, a Republican senator from Wisconsin, split from the GOP to form a new Progressive Party. La Follette's Progressives were motivated by the conservatism of both major party candidates, as well as the ongoing farm crisis,[129] they hoped to throw the election to the House by denying the Republican ticket an electoral vote majority, and some Progressives hoped to permanently disrupt the two-party system.[130] On the other hand, many believed that the split in the Republican party, like the one in 1912, would allow a Democrat to win the presidency.[131]

1924 electoral vote results

After the conventions and the death of his younger son Calvin, Coolidge became withdrawn; he later said that "when he [the son] died, the power and glory of the Presidency went with him."[132] It was the most subdued campaign since 1896, partly because of Coolidge's grief, but also because of his naturally non-confrontational style.[133] Coolidge relied on advertising executive Bruce Barton to lead his messaging campaign, and Barton's ads depicted Coolidge as a symbol of solidity in an era of speculation,[134] although the Harding administration had been tarred by several scandals, by 1924 several Democrats had also been implicated and the partisan responsibility of the issue had been muddled.[135] Coolidge and Dawes won every state outside the South except Wisconsin, La Follette's home state. Coolidge won 54% of the popular vote, while Davis took just 28.8% and La Follette won 16.6%, one of the strongest third party presidential showings in U.S. history. In the concurrent congressional elections, Republicans increased their majorities in the House and Senate.[136]

1926 midterm elections[edit]

Republicans lost seats in both the House and Senate in the 1926 midterm elections, but retained a majority in both houses, the reduced number of seats deprived Coolidge's conservative allies of a working majority in Congress.[137]

Election of 1928[edit]

1928 electoral vote results

After the 1924 election, many pundits assumed that Coolidge would seek another term in 1928, but Coolidge had other plans. While on vacation in mid-1927, Coolidge issued a terse statement that he would not seek a second full term as president;[138] in his memoirs, Coolidge explained his decision not to run: "The Presidential office takes a heavy toll of those who occupy it and those who are dear to them. While we should not refuse to spend and be spent in the service of our country, it is hazardous to attempt what we feel is beyond our strength to accomplish."[139] With Coolidge's retirement, speculation on the 1928 Republican presidential nominee focused on Senator Charles Curtis, Senator William Borah, former Governor Frank Lowden, Vice President Dawes, former Secretary of State Hughes, and, especially, Secretary of Commerce Herbert Hoover.[140] Coolidge was reluctant to endorse Hoover as his successor; on one occasion he remarked that "for six years that man has given me unsolicited advice—all of it bad."[141] Hoover also faced opposition from Mellon and other conservatives due to Hoover's progressive stance on some issues.[142] Hoover's standing at the head of the party was solidified by his handling of the Great Mississippi Flood, and he faced little opposition at the 1928 Republican National Convention.[143] Accepting the presidential nomination, Hoover stated, "we in America today are nearer to the final triumph over poverty than ever before in the history of any land...given the chance to go forward with the policies of the last eight years, we shall soon with the help of God be in sight of the day when poverty will be banished from this nation."[144]

Having been badly defeated in the last two presidential elections, and still facing bitter divisions between the Southern and Northeastern wings of the party, few Democrats believed their party would win the 1928 presidential election. By the time of the 1928 Democratic National Convention, Smith had emerged as the prohibitive favorite for the presidential nomination. Like Hoover, Smith was nominated on the first ballot of his party's national convention, while Senator Joseph T. Robinson of Arkansas was chosen as the vice presidential nominee.[145] Smith's policies differed little from those of Hoover, and the campaign instead centered on Smith's character, Catholicism, and opposition to Prohibition.[146] Hoover won a landslide victory, even taking Smith's home state of New York and several states in the Solid South.[147]

Historical reputation[edit]

Coolidge was generally popular during his presidency, but the onset of the Great Depression in 1929 damaged his reputation, as many linked the economic troubles to Coolidge's economic policies. Coolidge's reputation in foreign policy also suffered in the 1930s as it became clear that the Dawes Plan and other policies had done little to prevent the rise of international hostilities; in the 1980s, Ronald Reagan and other conservatives looked to the Coolidge administration as a model of laissez-faire policy.[148] Ferrell praises Coolidge for avoiding major scandals and reducing the debt, but criticizes Coolidge's inactivity in foreign policy and his failure to respond to rising stock market speculation.[149]

Polls of historians and political scientists have generally ranked Coolidge as a below-average president. A 2018 poll of the American Political Science Association’s Presidents and Executive Politics section ranked Coolidge as the 28th best president.[150] A 2017 C-Span poll of historians ranked Coolidge as the 27th best president.[151] Greenberg writes:

Scholarly opinion looks upon the Coolidge presidency with skepticism, ranking him relatively low among American chief executives in terms of his administration's positive impact and legacy, despite his personal integrity, he offered no sweeping vision or program of action that the presidencies of Theodore Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson had led the public to associate with presidential greatness.[148]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Sobel, pp. 12–13; Greenberg, pp. 1–7.
  2. ^ a b Fuess, pp. 308–09.
  3. ^ Fuess, pp. 310–15.
  4. ^ Fuess, pp. 328–29; Sobel, pp. 248–49.
  5. ^ Shlaes, p. 271.
  6. ^ a b Fuess, pp. 320–22.
  7. ^ Greenberg, pp. 48–49.
  8. ^ Rusnak, pp. 270-271.
  9. ^ Polsky, pp. 224-27.
  10. ^ Greenberg, pp. 111–112.
  11. ^ Ferrell, p. 31.
  12. ^ a b "Charles G. Dawes, 30th Vice President (1925-1929)". US Senate. Archived from the original on 6 November 2014. Retrieved 2 February 2017. 
  13. ^ Fuess, p. 364.
  14. ^ Galston, passim.
  15. ^ Greenberg, p. 110.
  16. ^ Freeman, p. 216.
  17. ^ Greenberg, pp. 49–53.
  18. ^ Ferrell, pp. 47–48.
  19. ^ Shlaes, p. 324.
  20. ^ a b Greenberg, pp. 68-69.
  21. ^ Miller, pp. 274, 281.
  22. ^ Miller, pp. 150–151.
  23. ^ Ferrell, p. 72.
  24. ^ a b Greenberg, pp. 12–13.
  25. ^ Ferrell, pp. 66–72; Sobel, p. 318.
  26. ^ Ferrell, pp. 71–72.
  27. ^ Greenberg, pp. 146–148.
  28. ^ Greenberg, pp. 72–73.
  29. ^ Ferrell, p. 70.
  30. ^ Ferrell, pp. 64–65.
  31. ^ Ferrell, pp. 32–33.
  32. ^ Greenberg, pp. 131–132.
  33. ^ Miller, pp. 318–319.
  34. ^ Ferrell, p. 32.
  35. ^ Ferrell, pp. 100–101.
  36. ^ Polsky, pp. 226-27.
  37. ^ Ferrell, p. 207.
  38. ^ Sobel, Robert. "Coolidge and American Business". John F. Kennedy Library and Museum. Archived from the original on March 8, 2006. 
  39. ^ Greenberg, p. 47; Ferrell, p. 62.
  40. ^ Keller, p. 780.
  41. ^ Sobel, pp. 310–11; Greenberg, pp. 127–29.
  42. ^ Greenberg, pp. 71-72.
  43. ^ Fuess, p. 341.
  44. ^ Greenberg, pp. 77–79.
  45. ^ Greenberg, pp. 79–80.
  46. ^ Sobel, pp. 310–11; Fuess, pp. 382–83.
  47. ^ Sobel, pp. 278–79.
  48. ^ Greenberg, p. 128.
  49. ^ Ferrell, pp. 169–171.
  50. ^ Ferrell, p. 26.
  51. ^ Greenberg, pp. 3.
  52. ^ a b c d Greenberg, pp. 82-84.
  53. ^ a b Herring (2008), pp. 467–468
  54. ^ Ferrell, pp. 113.
  55. ^ Ferrell, pp. 113–114.
  56. ^ Miller, pp. 148–149.
  57. ^ Ferrell, pp. 114–115.
  58. ^ Ferrell, p. 41.
  59. ^ Ferrell, pp. 81–83.
  60. ^ Williams, pp. 216-218.
  61. ^ Ferrell, p. 83.
  62. ^ Ferrell, pp. 83–84.
  63. ^ Ferrell, pp. 85–88.
  64. ^ Ferrell, pp. 88–89.
  65. ^ a b Fuess, pp. 383–84.
  66. ^ a b Ferrell, p. 89.
  67. ^ Ferrell, p. 90.
  68. ^ a b Sobel, p. 327.
  69. ^ Ferrell, pp. 89–90.
  70. ^ Ferrell, pp. 90–93.
  71. ^ a b Fuess, p. 388; Ferrell, p. 93.
  72. ^ Sobel, p. 331.
  73. ^ Ferrell, p. 86.
  74. ^ Williams, pp. 230-231.
  75. ^ a b Sobel, p. 315; Barry, pp. 286–87; Greenberg, pp. 132–35.
  76. ^ Miller, p. 344.
  77. ^ McCoy, pp. 330–31.
  78. ^ Barry, pp. 372–74.
  79. ^ Greenberg, p. 135.
  80. ^ Ferrell, pp. 73–74.
  81. ^ Ferrell, pp. 75–76.
  82. ^ Ferrell, pp. 78–80.
  83. ^ Huckabee, David C. (September 30, 1997). "Ratification of Amendments to the U.S. Constitution" (PDF). Congressional Research Service reports. Washington D.C.: Congressional Research Service, The Library of Congress. 
  84. ^ Greenberg, p. 76.
  85. ^ "Four amendments that almost made it into the constitution". Constitution Daily. Philadelphia: The National Constitution Center. March 23, 2014. Retrieved March 3, 2017. 
  86. ^ Vile, John R. (2003). Encyclopedia of Constitutional Amendments, Proposed Amendments, and Amending Issues, 1789-2002. ABC-CLIO. p. 63. ISBN 9781851094288. 
  87. ^ Ferrell, pp. 105–106.
  88. ^ Miller, pp. 137–138.
  89. ^ Ferrell, pp. 106–107.
  90. ^ Miller, pp. 296–297, 301.
  91. ^ Ferrell, p. 107.
  92. ^ Sobel, p. 250; McCoy, pp. 328–29.
  93. ^ a b Wikisource:Calvin Coolidge's First State of the Union Address
  94. ^ Felzenberg, pp. 83–96.
  95. ^ Sobel, pp. 249–50.
  96. ^ Ferrell, pp. 109–110.
  97. ^ Madsen, Deborah L., ed. (2015). The Routledge Companion to Native American Literature. Routledge. p. 168. ISBN 1317693191. 
  98. ^ Charles Kappler (1929). "Indian affairs: laws and treaties Vol. IV, Treaties". Government Printing Office. Retrieved 2008-10-14. 
  99. ^ Alysa Landry, "Calvin Coolidge: First Sitting Prez Adopted by Tribe Starts Desecration of Mount Rushmore", Indian Country Today, 26 July 2016; accessed same day
  100. ^ Deloria, p. 91.
  101. ^ Sobel, p. 342.
  102. ^ a b McCoy, pp. 184–85.
  103. ^ McCoy, p. 360.
  104. ^ McCoy, p. 363.
  105. ^ a b Greenberg, pp. 114–16.
  106. ^ Greenberg, pp. 88–90.
  107. ^ Herring (2008), pp. 459–460
  108. ^ Fuess, pp. 421–23.
  109. ^ McCoy, pp. 380–81; Greenberg, pp. 123–24.
  110. ^ Keller, p. 778.
  111. ^ Miller, p. 349.
  112. ^ Greenberg, pp. 117–119.
  113. ^ Herring (2008), p. 477
  114. ^ Fuess, pp. 414–17; Ferrell, pp. 122–23.
  115. ^ Herring (2008), p. 473
  116. ^ "Travels of President Calvin Coolidge". U.S. Department of State Office of the Historian. 
  117. ^ "Calvin Coolidge: Foreign Affairs". millercenter.org. Miller Center of Public Affairs, University of Virginia. Archived from the original on February 20, 2016. Retrieved February 24, 2016. 
  118. ^ Kim, Susanna (December 18, 2014). "Here's What Happened the Last Time a US President Visited Cuba". ABC News. Retrieved March 1, 2016. 
  119. ^ Herring (2008), pp. 471–472
  120. ^ Herring (2008), pp. 467–470
  121. ^ Sobel, pp. 226–28; Fuess, pp. 303–05; Ferrell, pp. 43–51.
  122. ^ Zieger, pp. 566-581.
  123. ^ Ferrell, pp. 53–54.
  124. ^ a b Fuess, pp. 345–46.
  125. ^ Greenberg, pp. 91–94.
  126. ^ Ferrell, pp. 55–57.
  127. ^ Ferrell, pp. 57–58.
  128. ^ Miller, p. 165.
  129. ^ Shideler, pp. 448-449.
  130. ^ Shideler, pp. 449-450.
  131. ^ Sobel, p. 300.
  132. ^ Coolidge 1929, p. 190.
  133. ^ Sobel, pp. 302–03.
  134. ^ Buckley, pp. 616–17.
  135. ^ Bates, pp. 319-323.
  136. ^ Greenberg, pp. 106–107.
  137. ^ Busch, Andrew (1999). Horses in Midstream. University of Pittsburgh Press. p. 157. 
  138. ^ Cyril Clemens and Athern P. Daggett, "Coolidge's 'I Do Not Choose to Run': Granite or Putty?." New England Quarterly (1945) 19#2: 147-163. online
  139. ^ Coolidge 1929, p. 239.
  140. ^ Miller, p. 342.
  141. ^ Ferrell, p. 195.
  142. ^ Miller, pp. 342–343.
  143. ^ Miller, pp. 348, 351.
  144. ^ Miller, p. 359.
  145. ^ Miller, pp. 351–352.
  146. ^ Miller, pp. 360–361.
  147. ^ Miller, pp. 362–363.
  148. ^ a b Greenberg, David. "CALVIN COOLIDGE: IMPACT AND LEGACY". Miller Center. Retrieved 4 December 2017. 
  149. ^ Ferrell, pp. 206–207.
  150. ^ Rottinghaus, Brandon; Vaughn, Justin S. (19 February 2018). "How Does Trump Stack Up Against the Best — and Worst — Presidents?". New York Times. Retrieved 14 May 2018. 
  151. ^ "Presidential Historians Survey 2017". C-Span. Retrieved 14 May 2018. 

Bibliography[edit]

Scholarly sources[edit]

Articles[edit]

  • Bates, J. Leonard (January 1955). "The Teapot Dome Scandal and the Election of 1924". The American Historical Review. 60 (2): 303–322. doi:10.2307/1843188. JSTOR 1843188. 
  • Buckley, Kerry W. (December 2003). "'A President for the "Great Silent Majority': Bruce Barton's Construction of Calvin Coolidge". The New England Quarterly. 76 (4): 593–626. doi:10.2307/1559844. JSTOR 1559844. 
  • Clemens, Cyril, and Athern P. Daggett, "Coolidge's 'I Do Not Choose to Run': Granite or Putty?." New England Quarterly (1945) 19#2: 147-163. online
  • Felzenberg, Alvin S. (Fall 1998). "Calvin Coolidge and Race: His Record in Dealing with the Racial Tensions of the 1920s". New England Journal of History. 55 (1): 83–96. 
  • Galston, Miriam (November 1995). "Activism and Restraint: The Evolution of Harlan Fiske Stone's Judicial Philosophy". 70 Tul. L. Rev. 137. 
  • Keller, Robert R. (3 September 1982). "Supply-Side Economic Policies during the Coolidge-Mellon Era". Journal of Economic Issues. 16 (3): 773–790. doi:10.1080/00213624.1982.11504032. JSTOR 4225215. 
  • Polsky, Andrew J.; Tkacheva, Olesya (Winter 2002). "Legacies versus Politics: Herbert Hoover, Partisan Conflict, and the Symbolic Appeal of Associationalism in the 1920s". International Journal of Politics, Culture, and Society. 16 (2): 207–235. doi:10.1023/a:1020525029722. JSTOR 20020160. 
  • Rusnak, Robert J. (Spring 1983). "Andrew W. Mellon: Reluctant Kingmaker". Presidential Studies Quarterly. 13 (2): 269–278. JSTOR 27547924. 
  • Shideler, James H. (June 1950). "The La Follette Progressive Party Campaign of 1924". The Wisconsin Magazine of History. 33 (4): 444–457. JSTOR 4632172. 
  • Williams, C. Fred (Spring 1996). "William M. Jardine and the Foundations for Republican Farm Policy, 1925-1929". Agricultural History. 70 (2): 216–232. JSTOR 3744534. 
  • Zieger, Robert H. (December 1965). "Pinchot and Coolidge: The Politics of the 1923 Anthracite Crisis". The Journal of American History. 52 (3): 566–581. doi:10.2307/1890848. 

Primary sources[edit]

External links[edit]