Anita Hill

Anita Hill
Anita Hill and Charles Ogletree at Brandeis University in September 2014
Born	Anita Faye Hill (1956-07-30) July 30, 1956 (age 61)[1] Lone Tree, Oklahoma, U.S.
Residence	Massachusetts[2]
Nationality	American
Education	Attorney
Alma mater	Oklahoma State University Yale University
Occupation	Attorney, professor
Years active	1983–present
Employer	Brandeis University
Known for	Testimony against Clarence Thomas
Board member of	Board of Trustees, Southern Vermont College
Awards	Fletcher Foundation Fellowship; Louis P. and Evelyn Smith First Amendment Award

Anita Faye Hill (born July 30, 1956) is an American attorney and academic. She is a University Professor of Social Policy, Law, and Women's Studies at Brandeis University and a faculty member of Brandeis' Heller School for Social Policy and Management.^[3] She became a national figure in 1991 when she accused U.S. Supreme Court nominee Clarence Thomas, her boss at the United States Department of Education and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, of sexual harassment.^[4]

Early life[edit]

Hill was born in Lone Tree, Oklahoma, the youngest of the 13 children of Albert and Erma Hill, who were farmers,^[4][5] her family came from Arkansas, where her great-grandparents and her maternal grandfather, Henry Eliot, were born into slavery.^[6] Hill was raised in the Baptist faith.^[4]

After graduating as valedictorian from Morris High School, Oklahoma she enrolled at Oklahoma State University, receiving a bachelor's degree with honors in psychology in 1977.^[4][5] She went on to Yale Law School, obtaining her Juris Doctor degree with honors in 1980.^[4][7]

She was admitted to the District of Columbia Bar in 1980 and began her law career as an associate with the Washington, D.C. firm of Wald, Harkrader & Ross. In 1981, she became an attorney-adviser to Clarence Thomas who was then the Assistant Secretary of the U.S. Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights. When Thomas became chairman of the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) in 1982, Hill went along to serve as his assistant, leaving the job in 1983.

Hill then became an assistant professor at the Evangelical Christian O. W. Coburn School of Law at Oral Roberts University where she taught from 1983 to 1986.^[8] In 1986, she joined the faculty at the University of Oklahoma College of Law where she taught commercial law and contracts.^[9][10]

Clarence Thomas controversy[edit]

In 1991, President George H. W. Bush nominated Clarence Thomas, by then a federal Circuit Judge, to succeed retiring Associate Justice Thurgood Marshall on the Supreme Court. Senate hearings on his confirmation were initially completed^[11] with Thomas's good character being presented as a primary qualification for the high court because he had only been a judge for slightly more than one year.^[12] There had been little organized opposition to Thomas's nomination, and his confirmation seemed assured^[12] until a report of a private interview of Hill by the FBI was leaked to the press,^[11][13] the hearings were then reopened, and Hill was called to publicly testify.^[11][13] Hill said in the October 1991 televised hearings that Thomas had sexually harassed her while he was her supervisor at the Department of Education and the EEOC. When questioned on why she followed Thomas to the second job after he had already allegedly harassed her, she said working in a reputable position within the civil rights field had been her ambition, the position was appealing enough to inhibit her to go back into private practice with her previous firm. She only realized later in her life that this ambitious venture was a poor judgment and also explained that "at that time, it appeared that the sexual overtures ... had ended."^[5][14]

According to Hill, during her two years of employment as Thomas's assistant, Thomas had asked her out socially many times,^[7] and after she refused, he used work situations to discuss sexual subjects.^[5][7] "He spoke about...such matters as women having sex with animals and films showing group sex or rape scenes," she said, adding that on several occasions Thomas graphically described "his own sexual prowess" and the details of his anatomy.^[5] Hill also recounted an instance in which Thomas examined a can of Coke on his desk and asked, "Who has put pubic hair on my Coke?"^[5] During court session, Republican Senator Orrin Hatch implied that "Hill was working in tandem with 'slick lawyers' and interest groups bent on destroying Thomas' chances to join the court". Thomas said he considered Hill a friend whom he had helped at every turn, so when accusations of harassment came from her they were particularly hurtful and he said, "I lost the belief that if I did my best, all would work out."

Four female witnesses reportedly waited in the wings to support Hill's credibility, but they were not called,^[13][15] due to what the Los Angeles Times described as a private, compromise deal between Republicans and the Senate Judiciary Committee Chair, Democrat Joe Biden.^[16] According to Time magazine, one of the witnesses, Angela Wright, may not have been considered credible on the issue of sexual harassment because she had been fired from the EEOC by Thomas.^[15]

Hill agreed to take a polygraph test. While senators and other authorities noted that polygraph results cannot be relied upon and are inadmissible in courts, Hill's results did support her statements.^[17] Thomas did not take a polygraph test, he made a vehement and complete denial, saying that he was being subjected to a "high-tech lynching for uppity blacks" by white liberals who were seeking to block a black conservative from taking a seat on the Supreme Court.^[18][19] After extensive debate, the United States Senate confirmed Thomas to the Supreme Court by a vote of 52–48, the narrowest margin since the 19th century.^{[15][20][dead link]}

Thomas's supporters questioned Hill's credibility, claiming she was delusional or had been spurned, leading her to seek revenge,^[13] they cited the time delay of ten years between the alleged behavior by Thomas and Hill's accusations, and noted that Hill had followed Thomas to a second job and later had personal contacts with Thomas, including giving him a ride to an airport—behavior which they said would be inexplicable if Hill's allegations were true.^{[7][9][13][21]} Hill countered that she had come forward because she felt an obligation to share information on the character and actions of a person who was being considered for the Supreme Court,^[13] she testified that after leaving the EEOC, she had had two "inconsequential" phone conversations with Thomas, and had seen him personally on two occasions, once to get a job reference and the second time when he made a public appearance in Oklahoma where she was teaching.^[5]

Doubts about the veracity of Hill's 1991 testimony persisted long after Thomas took his seat on the Court, they were furthered by American Spectator writer David Brock in his 1993 book The Real Anita Hill,^[15] though he later recanted the claims he had made, described in his book as "character assassination," and apologized to Hill.^[22][23] After interviewing a number of women who alleged that Thomas had frequently subjected them to sexually explicit remarks, Wall Street Journal reporters Jane Mayer and Jill Abramson wrote a book which concluded that Thomas had lied during his confirmation process.^[20][24] Richard Lacayo in his 1994 review of the book for Time magazine remarked, however, that "Their book doesn't quite nail that conclusion."^[15] In 2007, Kevin Merida, a coauthor of another book on Thomas, remarked that what happened between Thomas and Hill was "ultimately unknowable" by others, but that it was clear that "one of them lied, period."^[25][26] Writing in 2007, Neil Lewis of The New York Times remarked that, "To this day, each side in the epic he-said, she-said dispute has its unmovable believers."^[27]

In 2007, Thomas published his autobiography, My Grandfather's Son, in which he revisited the controversy, calling Hill his "most traitorous adversary" and saying that pro-choice liberals, who feared that he would vote to overturn Roe v. Wade if he were seated on the Supreme Court, used the scandal against him.^[27] He described Hill as touchy and apt to overreact, and her work at the EEOC as mediocre,^[27][28] he acknowledged that three other former EEOC employees had backed Hill's story, but said they had all left the agency on bad terms.^[28] He also wrote that Hill "was a left-winger who'd never expressed any religious sentiments whatsoever...and the only reason why she'd held a job in the Reagan administration was because I'd given it to her."^[29] Hill denied the accusations in an op-ed in The New York Times saying she would not "stand by silently and allow [Justice Thomas], in his anger, to reinvent me".^[2][30]

In October 2010, Thomas's wife Virginia, a conservative activist, left a voicemail at Hill's office asking that Hill apologize for her 1991 testimony. Hill initially believed the call was a hoax and referred the matter to the Brandeis University campus police who alerted the FBI,^[19][31] after being informed that the call was indeed from Virginia Thomas, Hill told the media that she did not believe the message was meant to be conciliatory and said, "I testified truthfully about my experience and I stand by that testimony."^[19] Virginia Thomas responded that the call had been intended as an "olive branch".^[19]

Effects[edit]

Shortly after the Thomas confirmation hearings, President George H. W. Bush dropped his opposition to a bill giving harassment victims the right to seek federal damage awards, back pay and reinstatement, and the law was passed by Congress.^[32][33] One year later, harassment complaints filed with the EEOC were up 50 percent and public opinion had shifted in Hill's favor.^[33] Private companies also started training programs to deter sexual harassment.^[32] When journalist Cinny Kennard asked Hill in 1991 if she would testify against Thomas all over again, Hill answered, "I'm not sure if I could have lived with myself if I had answered those questions any differently."^[34]

The manner in which the all-male Senate Judiciary Committee challenged and dismissed Hill's accusations of sexual harassment angered women politicians and lawyers.^[35] According to D.C. Congressional Delegate Eleanor Holmes Norton, Hill's treatment by the panel also said to be a contributing factor to the large number of women elected to Congress in 1992, "women clearly went to the polls with the notion in mind that you had to have more women in Congress", she said.^[2] In their anthology, All the Women Are White, All the Blacks Are Men, but Some of Us Are Brave, editors Gloria T. Hull, Patricia Bell-Scott, and Barbara Smith described black feminists mobilizing "a remarkable national response to the Anita Hill-Clarence Thomas controversy.^[36]

In 1992, a feminist group began a nationwide fundraising campaign and then obtained matching state funds to endow a professorship at the University of Oklahoma Law School in honor of Hill.^[10][37] Conservative Oklahoma state legislators reacted by demanding Hill's resignation from the university, then introducing a bill to prohibit the university from accepting donations from out-of-state residents, and finally attempting to pass legislation to close down the law school.^[10] Elmer Zinn Million, a local activist and organized protester who was caught up by the zeal compared Hill to the assassin of President Kennedy,^[10][37] he was known as the "one-armed man" by the Oklahoma Observer.^{[citation needed]} Certain officials at the university attempted to revoke Hill's tenure,^[38] after five years of pressure, Hill resigned.^[10] The University of Oklahoma Law School defunded the Anita F. Hill professorship in May 1999, without the position having ever been filled.

Later career[edit]

Hill accepted a position as a visiting scholar at the Institute for the Study of Social Change at University of California, Berkeley in January, 1997,^[39] but soon joined the faculty of Brandeis University—first at the Women's Studies Program, later moving to the Heller School for Social Policy and Management. In 2011, she also took a counsel position with the Civil Rights & Employment Practice group of the plaintiffs' law firm Cohen Milstein Sellers & Toll.^[8]

Over the years, Hill has provided commentary on gender and race issues on national television programs, including 60 Minutes, Face the Nation and Meet the Press.^[4][8] She has been a speaker on the topic of commercial law as well as race and women's rights,^[8] she is also the author of articles that have been published in The New York Times and Newsweek^[4][8] and has contributed to many scholarly and legal publications in the areas of international commercial law, bankruptcy, and civil rights.^[8][40]

In 1995 Hill co-edited Race, Gender and Power in America: The Legacy of the Hill-Thomas Hearings with Emma Coleman Jordan.^[4][41] In 1997 Hill published her autobiography, Speaking Truth to Power,^{[42][page needed]} in which she chronicled her role in the Clarence Thomas confirmation controversy^[4][6] and wrote that creating a better society had been a motivating force in her life.^[43] She contributed the piece "The Nature of the Beast: Sexual Harassment" to the 2003 anthology Sisterhood Is Forever: The Women's Anthology for a New Millennium, edited by Robin Morgan.^[44] In 2011 Hill published her second book, Reimagining Equality: Stories of Gender, Race, and Finding Home, which focuses on the sub-prime lending crisis that resulted in the foreclosure of many homes owned by African-Americans.^[13][45] She calls for a new understanding about the importance of a home and its place in the American Dream,^[6] on March 26, 2015, the Brandeis Board of Trustees unanimously voted to recognize Hill with a promotion to Private University Professor of Social Policy, Law, and Women's Studies.^[46]

In popular culture[edit]

In 1999, Ernest Dickerson directed Strange Justice, a film based on Anita vs. Clarence Thomas controversy, her case also inspired the 1994 Law & Order episode "Virtue", about a young lawyer who feels pressured to sleep with her supervisor at her law firm.^[47] Hill was the subject of the 2013 documentary film Anita by director Freida Lee Mock, which chronicles her experience during the Clarence Thomas scandal.^[48][49] Hill was portrayed by actress Kerry Washington in the 2016 HBO film Confirmation.^[50] Hill is mentioned in the 1992 Sonic Youth song "Youth Against Fascism", the Clarence Thomas scandal is mentioned in the 1994 Rugrats episode "Mommy's Little Assets."

Written works[edit]

External video

Booknotes interview with Hill on Speaking Truth to Power, November 23, 1997, C-SPAN[51]

On October 20, 1998, Anita Hill published the book Speaking Truth to Power. Throughout much of the book she gives details on her side of the sexual harassment controversy, and her professional relationship with Clarence Thomas. Aside from that, she also provides a glimpse of what her personal life was like all the way from her childhood days growing up in Oklahoma to her position as a law professor.^{[42][page needed]}

In 2011, Hill’s second book, Reimagining Equality: Stories of Gender, Race, and Finding Home was published .^[52] She discusses the relationship between the home and the American Dream, she also exposes the inequalities within gender and race and home ownership. She argues that inclusive democracy is more important than debates about legal rights, she uses her own history and history of other African American women such as Nannie Helen Burroughs, in order to strengthen her argument for reimagining equality altogether.

In 1994, she wrote a tribute to Thurgood Marshall, the first African American Supreme Court Justice who preceded Clarence Thomas, titled A Tribute to Thurgood Marshall: A Man Who Broke with Tradition on Issues of Race and Gender^[53]. She notes Thurgood’s contributions to the principles of equality as a judge and how his work has affected the lives of African Americans, specifically African American women.

Anita F. Hill became a proponent for women’s rights and feminism, this can be seen through the chapter she wrote in the book Women and leadership: the state of play and strategies for change.^[54] She wrote about women judges and why, in her opinion, they play such a large role in balancing the judicial system, she argues that since women and men have different life experiences, ways of thinking, and histories, both are needed for a balanced court system. She writes that in order for the best law system to be created in the United States, all people need the ability to be represented.

Awards and recognition[edit]

In 2005, Hill was selected as a Fletcher Foundation Fellow; in 2008 she was awarded the Louis P. and Evelyn Smith First Amendment Award^[55] by the Ford Hall Forum. She also serves on the Board of Trustees for Southern Vermont College in Bennington, Vermont,^[56] her opening statement to the Senate Judiciary Committee in 1991 is listed as #69 in American Rhetoric's Top 100 Speeches of the 20th Century (listed by rank).^[57][58] She was inducted into the Oklahoma Women's Hall of Fame in 1993,^[59] on January 7, 2017, Hill was inducted as an honorary member of Zeta Phi Beta sorority at their National Executive Board Meeting in Dallas, Texas.^[60]

See also[edit]

• Clarence Thomas Supreme Court nomination
• Sexual harassment

References[edit]

External links[edit]

• Faculty profile at Brandeis University
• Appearances on C-SPAN
• Audio lecture: Anita Hill discusses Reimagining Equality: Stories of Gender, Race, and Finding Home on October 4, 2011, on Forum Network.
• An Outline of the Anita Hill and Clarence Thomas Controversy at Roy Rosenzweig Center for History and New Media